Evidence: Commentary & Materials 8th edition

Evidence: Commentary & Materials 8th edition

By Andrew Hemming, Miiko Kumar, Elisabeth Peden


$168.00 RRP

Date: 14/08/2013

Code: 9780455230733

Thomson Reuters, AUSTRALIA

Available Formats

Format Title Date Code Price
Book Evidence: Commentary & Materials 8th edition 14/08/2013 9780455230733 $168.00 Add to cart
Book+eBook Evidence: Commentary and Materials 8th Book + eBook 14/08/2013 41498004 $224.00 Add to cart
eBook - ProView Evidence: Commentary and Materials 8th eBook 09/08/2013 9780455232041 $168.00 Add to cart


Evidence: Commentary and Materials 8th Edition introduces general principles and theoretical perspectives of the law of evidence, covering all Australian jurisdictions and explaining State by State variations.

The most significant change since the previous edition is the expansion of the Uniform Evidence Acts (UEA) into Victoria, the Australian Capital Territory and the Northern Territory, leaving Queensland, Western Australia and South Australia as the remaining common law States. As a result, legislative references have been updated throughout, replacing Victorian references with examples from Queensland and South Australia.

Up until now, cases from New South Wales have dominated the UEAs but Victoria will provide a counterbalance in future, as evidenced by Dupas v The Queen, where the Victorian Court of Appeal declined to follow New South Wales authority. This inconsistency between Victoria and New South Wales has been brought into sharper focus following the decision in R v XY, where the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal preferred its own previous authority in R v Shamouil to that of Victoria’s in Dupas v The Queen. The disparity between New South Wales and Victoria will most likely have to be resolved by the High Court.

Another important change is the amendment of the UEAs following a review by the ALRC, which has included amendments to allow second-hand or remote hearsay subject to the exceptions relating to admissions in criminal proceedings. Other developments include expansion of the freshness rule to cover other considerations apart from time; amendments to the UEA credibility provisions; and recent legislative reform to the right to silence in New South Wales.

New cases covered in this edition include:

  • Baker v The Queen (hearsay exclusionary rule);
  • HML v The Queen and Asplin v Western Australia (similar fact evidence);
  • Lithgow City Council v Jackson and Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (High Court interpretations on opinion evidence);
  • Robinson v Woolworths Ltd, Fleming v The Queen, and DPP v Marijancevic (discretion to exclude illegally or improperly obtained evidence);
  •  Braysich v The Queen, and Strong v Woolworths (burden and standard of proof);
  • Evans v The Queen (relevance and documents); and
  • AK v State of Western Australia (visual identificaiton evidence).

Table of Contents

1 Introduction

2 Competence and compellability 

3 The burden and standard of proof

4 Presumptions

5 Prima facie case

6 Privilege

7 The examination of witnesses

8 Disposition and character

9 Propensity or similar fact evidence

10 The accused as a witness

11 Identification evidence

12 Real evidence

13 Documentary evidence

14 Opinion evidence and prior determinations

15 Hearsay: the exclusionary rule

16 Hearsay: the common law and statutory exclusions

17 Confessions, admissions and statements made in the accused's presence

18 Illegally obtained evidence and confirmation by subsequent fact

19 Res gestae

20 Corroboration and judicial warnings in the case of suspect witnesses 

Got a Promo Code?